Me and my professor are disagreeing about the nature of logic. He claims that logic is prescribes norms for correct reasoning, and is thus normative. I claim that logic is governed by a few axioms (just like any in any other discipline, i.e. science) that one is asked to accept, and then follows deductively, free of any normative claims.
My question is: which side is more sound?
Read another response by Stephen Maitzen, Richard Heck
Read another response about Logic