What constitutes vulgar and obscene language: the heart or intended meaning, or the words in and of themseves? Are there words which are intrinsically bad, like the word "fuck" for instance. If I said "fuck you" that would definitely be a bad thing, but if I simply said "fuck that", implying that, for instance, I did not want anything to do with a particular thing, is that word still bad?
I'm inclined to think that there are differences of opinion about this, but my own view (for what it is worth) is that what counts as vulgar and obscene are a matter of cultural (and perhaps even situational) context. For one thing, the origin of the word "vulgar" simply associates a thing with the masses, or the common people--so identifying a term as "vulgar" really only associates that term with a certain social class. Only if we think of that class as a whole as somehow morally debased would vulgarity (in this sense) count as a kind of evil. But I understand that "vulgar" has lost its "classist" bias and now means something like "dirty" or "obscene." At any rate, the word "fuck" doesn't seem to me to have some intrinsic feature that makes it obscene. What it does have is a kind of resonance or set of connotations, which are culture-bound, that make its uses rude in "polite company." Now, some might object to the connections between the word "fuck" and the sex act to which it...
- Log in to post comments