What is the philosopher's response to the anthropic principle?

What is the philosopher's response to the anthropic principle?

What is the philosopher's response to the anthropic principle? (which, if I recall correctly, states that the universe "had to" evolve in a certain manner, otherwise we would not be here to ask these questions about it!) Is it dismissed as basically a tautology? or is there something more substantive behind it?

Read another response by Nicholas D. Smith
Read another response about Physics