Skip to main content

ask a question

recent responses

all topics

info

  • About this Site
  • Feeds
  • Publications
  • Panelists
  • Panelist Login

⚲

Animals
Ethics

Hello philosophers, there is a vast philosophical literature that defends animal rights and vegetarianism, but the opposite camp doesn't seem to have produced much. What is the equivalent of Singer's "Animal Liberation" in the "meat eating" camp? Or is this a dead subject among philosophers, where those who care write books about the defense of animals, while those who don't simply go ahead and eat their steaks? Thanks in advance for your valuable insight.

Amy Kind
October 29, 2009 (changed October 29, 2009) Permalink
I'm not sure that anyone has written the definitive treatise on Animal Enslavement , but you might check out The Animal Rights Debate . In this book, Tom Regan makes the case for animal rights, while Carl Cohen mounts a case against it.
  • Log in to post comments
  • Read more about Hello philosophers,
  • 2 comments
  • Log in to post comments
Animals
Ethics

Dear philosophers, I'd currently call myself a 'pseudo-vegetarian', in that I don't eat meat, but I do eat fish and dairy foods, and use other products derived from animals (e.g. leather, wool). I became a vegetarian when I was five; arguably, when it was easier for me to hold a black-and-white moral viewpoint. I would now like to re-evaluate my vegetarianism, so that I can make an informed and (hopefully) ethically coherent decision about the foods I eat and the products I use. Are there any books you could recommend for me to read? I studied some philosophy at university, and would be interested in reading some balanced discussions of animal rights, vegetarianism and veganism. Thank you for reading this e-mail, and thank you in advance for your help.

Amy Kind
April 2, 2009 (changed April 2, 2009) Permalink
Given the difficulty in finding balanced treatments of these issues, you might try to achieve a balance of your own by reading people with strong opinions on either side of the issue. So in addition to reading Singer's Animal Liberation , which is the classic statement of the position in favor of animal rights, you might also read Peter Carruthers' The Animals Issue , which argues that animals do not have moral standing.
  • Log in to post comments
  • Read more about Dear philosophers,
  • 2 comments
  • Log in to post comments