The AskPhilosophers logo.

Consciousness

How can a certain bunch of atoms be more self aware than another bunch?
Accepted:
September 16, 2015

Comments

Good question, but I hope you

Stephen Maitzen
September 17, 2015 (changed September 17, 2015) Permalink

Good question, but I hope you didn't intend it to be merely rhetorical.

Even at this early stage of our investigations, there's good evidence that the answer has to do with whether a given bunch of atoms composes a being that possesses a complex network of neurons. Some bunches of atoms, such as the bunch that composes me, do compose such a being. Other bunches, such as the bunch that composes my favorite pen, do not.

Notice that we're not tempted to regard any of these similar questions as rhetorical: How can a certain bunch of atoms be more red than another bunch? How can a certain bunch of atoms have better eyesight than another bunch? And so on. I regard the question you asked as in the same boat as those.

  • Log in to post comments
Source URL: https://askphilosophers.org/question/24743
© 2005-2025 AskPhilosophers.org