Topics Ethics

Question Is killing considered wrong because people have a right to be alive, or because the act of killing someone is immoral?

Accepted:
May 10, 2012

Comments

Good question. Some ethical systems have grounded the ethics against homicide on grounds that do not appeal to the right to life. For example, some divine command theories hold that you should not kill innocent persons because this is prohibited by God. And some utilitarians (Bentham) repudiate the appeal to rights. However, there are other philosophical systems in which rights are given foremost attention, and would claim that the reason why you should not kill the innocent is because they have a right to life. This way of putting the matter puts the focus on the person who has a right not to be violated and also leads us to think that if someone does attempt to kill an innocent person (and fails) that person is owed some restitution (the criminal act is not just a crime against the state or God, though it might be agains both; it is also a crime against the intended victim).

Question Is killing considered wrong because people have a right to be alive, or because the act of killing someone is immoral? Accepted:May 10, 2012

Question Is killing considered wrong because people have a right to be alive, or because the act of killing someone is immoral?

Accepted:
May 10, 2012