Topics Knowledge

Question Can I infer from the fact I am thinking that I have existed for a finite period of time (as opposed to simply "I exist"), irrespective of how short that period of time might be?

Accepted:
April 2, 2008

Comments

It depends. Descartes would say no. The strength of his famous argument "Cogito ergo sum" (I think, therefore I am) is its "performativity", that is, its power to realize what is stated by the simple fact of stating it. But this performative aspect is lost if we declinate the same sentence in a past form. "I think therefore I have existed sometime before now" is a completely different inference. If I say "I apologize" I'm apologizing, while if I say "I have apologized yesterday" I'm just describing a fact about my past life, whose truth-conditions depend on many variables.

Whereas G.E. Moore would say that this is commonsensical. In his essay "A Defense of Commonsense" , he writes: "There exists at present a living human body, which is my body.This body was born at a certain time in the past, and has existedcontinuously ever since, though not without undergoing changes; it was,for instance, much smaller when it was born, and for some timeafterwards, than it is now"

These are for him truisms, that is, commonsensical propositions that I can infer just from the fact that I'm here and able to think.

I'm not convinced by G.E. Moore commonsensical propositions, and I share your doubts about the fact that you can infer your past existence from you present state of mind. Descartes' performative argument is much stronger: if I'm thinking I can necessarily infer that I exist, but my past existence depends on a check of reality that goes beyon pure logical inference.

Question Can I infer from the fact I am thinking that I have existed for a finite period of time (as opposed to simply "I exist"), irrespective of how short that period of time might be? Accepted:April 2, 2008

Question Can I infer from the fact I am thinking that I have existed for a finite period of time (as opposed to simply "I exist"), irrespective of how short that period of time might be?

Accepted:
April 2, 2008