The AskPhilosophers logo.

Philosophers

I understand that Socrates went along with a death sentence because he believed it right to obey the laws of the country even when they were unjust. He had ample opportunity to escape into exile, and his friends encouraged him to do this, but he said no. Aristotle was a Macedonian. With the death of Alexander the Great in 323 BC there was very strong anti-Macedonian feeling in Athens. Aristotle became a target and he sought asylum in Chalcis. He did it because he did not want comply with what would have been an unjust law/judicial process and 'to prevent the people of Athens sinning a second time against philosophy' (Socrates being the first victim). So, did Aristotle think Socrates was virtuous in not taking up the opportunity to go into exile? Is it not also virtuous to find ways of surviving?
Accepted:
November 26, 2007

Comments

Oliver Leaman
December 13, 2007 (changed December 13, 2007) Permalink

I don't think Socrates thought the laws in Athens were unjust so much as that on this particular occasion they had been improperly applied. He refused to escape because he was in principle in agreement with Athenian culture and felt that he was therefore obliged to go along with its disadvantages as well as its advantages. As you say, there is no reason for Aristotle to be so motivated given his upbringing away from Athens. Socrates thought of Athens as his mother, as he says, and was not going to reject her even if she rejected him. Aristotle had no such relation to the city. Both thinkers would agree on the advisability of surviving, but for both not at any cost.

  • Log in to post comments
Source URL: https://askphilosophers.org/question/1900
© 2005-2025 AskPhilosophers.org