The AskPhilosophers logo.

Music

What is music? I can recognise music from cultures other than my own as being music, even if I don't enjoy it; but what makes a series of sounds 'music'? Similarly (I assume), when does human vocalising become song?
Accepted:
December 9, 2006

Comments

Peter S. Fosl
January 5, 2007 (changed January 5, 2007) Permalink

What a fascinating question. I hope that some of my co-panelists can give you the answer this question deserves. For myself, I would briefly and cautiously answer this way: What makes a series of sounds (or even a single sound or even a silence) music is our agreement to consider it as music. Just as John Cage invites people to consider the silence and random sounds that occur during a 4 minute and 33 second period music (his piece is called, 4' 33") and Marcel Duchamp invites people to consider a urinal as sculpture (he called the piece Fountain), we make something music when we interpret it as music.

  • Log in to post comments
Source URL: https://askphilosophers.org/question/1497
© 2005-2025 AskPhilosophers.org