The AskPhilosophers logo.

Justice

I’m a little ashamed for asking this question but I feel I’m in need of some guidance regarding politics. I reached the age where I’m allowed to vote quite some time ago, but to be honest feel if I did it would be more like filling in a lottery ticket rather than voting so I haven’t. There’s much of politics and our political system that I don’t understand. With all the rhetoric involved in the media it’s hard to know who to believe. Politicians could make these promises and break them as soon as they’re in. There seems to be so many variables involved and the whole thing’s a bit overwhelming. For example, maybe one particular policy sounds like a good idea and addresses an issue that’s close to me. But then what if the money used for this could be put to better use elsewhere? What if this solution helps in the short term, but puts us right up the creek after a decade? What the heck do I know about economics?? Should people like me (and I suspect there are many) leave the voting to those with the relevant expertise? If not, what should we do and how do we go about it? Is there an idiots guide to politics?
Accepted:
September 28, 2006

Comments

Nicholas D. Smith
October 3, 2006 (changed October 3, 2006) Permalink

Winston Churchill once claimed that "democracy is the worst form of government...except all the others that have been tried." On the other hand, he also once said, "the best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter."

There is wisdom in both of his quotes, I think. One problem with you (and others like you) refusing to vote is that others who have no advantage over you of any relevant kind, in terms of applicable expertise, will vote, and so you allow their ignorance to determine how you will be governed. That's Churchill's "best argument against democracy." On the other side of his musings on democracy, it remains true that--for all its flaws--democracy (even when ignorant "average voters" determine the outcomes of elections) remains the best of all of the actual ways human beings have actually tried to govern and be governed. So by opting out, you end up making the process less democratic than it would be with full participation--and thus more like the poorer forms of governing.

But you are also right to worry that you cannot be a fully responsible citizen unless you learn as much as you can about the issues. So do so!

  • Log in to post comments
Source URL: https://askphilosophers.org/question/1379
© 2005-2025 AskPhilosophers.org