The AskPhilosophers logo.

Language

Hi - My question is as follows It is possible for anyone ( alive or dead ) to 1.Make any kind of statement ( including those made in response to this question ) which is not a statement which claims that a. Something is possible ( or impossible ) b.Something is actual ( or not ) c.Something is necessary ( or not) Please note that I am NOT asking about the truth of the statement but only the form in which it is stated - So, for example - A statement which claims that 'Triangles have four sides' ( though false) could be classified as making the claim as a possibiliy, actuality or necessity ( subject to clarification by the maker of the statement ). Also if possible could I have a response to the isues of 'Explanation' what is an 'explanation' - I've often read in textbooks that some author is not offering an 'explanation' but rather a 'description'. Regards - Colin
Accepted:
September 19, 2006

Comments

Peter Lipton
September 21, 2006 (changed September 21, 2006) Permalink

Since 'p' entails 'it is possible that p', the answer to your first question seems to be no.

An answer to your second question is that a description says how something is while an explanation says why it is that way. You can think about this in terms of the contrast between knowing that p and understanding why p. Most people know that the same side of the moon always faces the earth; few people understand why.

  • Log in to post comments
Source URL: https://askphilosophers.org/question/1371
© 2005-2025 AskPhilosophers.org