Question Why is it ok to kill for your country no matter what the reason, but not ok to kill someone just because you don't like them? What is the difference?

Accepted:
December 27, 2005

Comments

It isn't OK to kill for your country no matter what the reason, and some think it isn't OK to kill for any reason whatsoever. Even in less dramatic circumstances few would argue that we are entitled to act without knowing why, and approving of the reason, although there might be circumstances in which one would have to trust leaders that they know why something ought to be done. As we know, leaders can sometimes be rather untrustworthy in this respect. I believe that many armies give their military personnel instructions that they are not to follow an illegal order, and so they are obliged to think about what they are doing, why they are doing it and how they could justify it if called upon to do so. That surely is the right approach.

Question Why is it ok to kill for your country no matter what the reason, but not ok to kill someone just because you don't like them? What is the difference? Accepted:December 27, 2005

Question Why is it ok to kill for your country no matter what the reason, but not ok to kill someone just because you don't like them? What is the difference?

Accepted:
December 27, 2005