Topics Identity

Question If I am made up of countless organisms, who is experiencing the independent thoughts?

Accepted:
November 20, 2005

Comments

*You* are. You, the person, are the subject of your thoughts; you are the one whose thoughts they are. The countless organisms you mention make up one big organism--the human organism that constitutes you. It seems to me a mistake to think that your brain is the subject of thought. Your brain is the organ by means of which you think, just as your legs are the limbs by means of which you walk.

There is a divide in philosophy (even today) among those who think that a subject of thought is immaterial (e.g., Plato, Descartes and his intellectual descendants) and those who think that subjects of thought can be fit into the material world (e.g., many who work in the sciences). It's really an interesting question. It seems to me reasonable to argue that subjects of thought are truly special--different in kind from other sorts of beings in the universe--and at the same to to deny that subjects of thought are immaterial. But, of course, many disagree!

Question If I am made up of countless organisms, who is experiencing the independent thoughts? Accepted:November 20, 2005

Question If I am made up of countless organisms, who is experiencing the independent thoughts?

Accepted:
November 20, 2005