Hello, I have a question about whether or not an ad hominem fallacy is committed as a response by Zed. Alan makes supported claims about TopicX. He also challenges claims made by Zed about TopicX, asking for the support of those claims. Zed: "You simply know very little about TopicX. As such, I can dismiss your claims as being the ravings of someone who doesn't know what he's talking about." Thoughts?

Read another response about Logic